Showing posts with label Critical Studies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Critical Studies. Show all posts

Sunday, September 20, 2009

Critical Studies 10 - In A Life Post-Us

In a life post-us


Does history matter? In a search through excavation of the archeological site Thomas Hirschhorn quoted "Does the passing of time only determine the significance?" (394) In the Hans Ulrich Obrist Interviews (2003). At which point did the trash of yesterday become today's artifacts of the past? Unanswered and ill explained, Hirschhorn describes the engagement of the people behind the working system of the world- from the highest power of the food chain to the lowest working at a fast food chain.

When all of the above comes to mind, what is happening with today's artwork tomorrow? In a world post-present, that is to say that we're living in a world where the technological rate doubles itself every 1.5 years- and advertising and media branding is flowing in and out of the brain and in and out of 'popularity' in mere weeks at a time, keeping up with the change seems impossible. As for art, the same is happening as one's 15 minutes of fame is in and out like the something. Hirschhorn rejected the idea that a catalogue is to legitimize an artwork and rather that it should 'inform, create knowledge and discuss connections and contexts' - where I believe true, such forms of discussion should exist in order to stimulate minds, they also act as a document of preservation (if lucky enough to succeed in an ISBN number). But such achievements surely would go unnoticed in the future, right?

Schopenhauer described living as an 'eternal frustration' (Schopenhauer 'The World As Will' 10), to live in a world without god, without meaning and direction, the proof seems to be in our lives- the fast past change in life seems that everything we do becomes a 'filler'. Easily arguable, existence has a cap, and what we do is crammed into a period of time. A world of subjects and objects as described in Schopenhauer’s world of will, each to be perceived and perceiving- inevitably living? It’s troubling to end on this note, but what are we to do with time in a troubled world of no direction.



Thomas Hirschhorn interview with Hans Ulrich Orbist, Thomas Boutiux ed., Hans Ulrich Orbist: Interview volume 1, Milan: Charta, 2003, pp.393-400.


"Arthur Schopenhauer." Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. May 12, 2003. Metaphysics Research Lab, CSLI, Stanford University. 18 September 2009 <
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/schopenhauer/>.

Critical Studies 9 - The son of mum and dad

mum, how is art born?

We are merely slaves to the art, artists as creators- mothers if you will to a child born into a world of waiting arms, outstretched willing (and unwilling in some cases) to nurture this child and judge him or her on a basis of looks. The aesthetic child, slave to the man, slave to the world we have created for ourselves in an effort to sell products, sell celebrities, to sell an image. You, you are a slave to this, you are a slave to this child, whether you like it or not, an abortion was not passed and you are here to view this child. As said in Bourriaud's 'Relational Aesthetics' a quote from Jean-Luc Godard 'It takes two to make an image' (Bourriaud 26). Subject and Object, Schopenhauer describes us in his World of Will, to perceive and be perceived- we are the perceivers each taking in objects around us, blurred lines as we (our bodies) become objects. Objects that (in our minds) should fit to the realization of an aesthetic world, as should art generally be perceived.

Each to their own do we come across 'art', it's expectations have changed, the move from sub culture and genres of art have clashed, defining one's practice is no longer 'one's' practice but rather a combined effort of "individuals and groups, between the artist and the world.. Between the beholder and the world" (Bourriaud 26). In such a world where one is no longer ones own, where an object does not exist without a subject (that is, if there is an object to be perceived but no subject to perceive it- how does it exist). Unnoticed. May we have lagged behind in the booming age of technology, we are now amongst it as the ability to communicate across seas, countries and even to beyond earth, there is a universal awareness we must take in to account. Awareness of art in its current state, which is constantly moving and adapting as technology changes itself. As for the change in state, slaves to the art, we may simply not need to be a creator for it, but merely just spectators as looking towards art may possibly just be enough.

..If that is not enough, then this program 'E-Icon' (http://www.numeral.com/eicon.html) brings some valid points to mind- if there was a super computer that created images based on combinations of pixels all moving through 256 colours and the infinite number of combinations then there could be images of you, me and everyone and everything in this world. If everything has been seen, and everything that has not is there anything left to do?


Nicolas Bourriaud, "Art of the 1990s", from Relational Aesthetics, Paris: les presses de reel, 2002, pp.25-40.

Mirapaul, Matthew. "In John Simon's Art, Everything Is Possible" 1997. The New York Times Company, 18 Sep 2009

Critical Studies 8 - More Than Real

More Than Real

What is it about images that we have become so desensitized to? Shredded bodies, corpses hung, flesh from bone is what Campbell talks of in his portrayal of devastating life from the captured media. When movies so easily reproduce such horrific events and unimaginable stories following the slaughtering of us, us humans, we see such things as a removed version of our self. Where we could still squeal at such thought of cutting off our own foot in blockbusters like SAW, it is the repeated imagery, the repeated number of movies revolving around the same intense pictures of the unimaginable not to mention the seven series of SAW that will appear in theatres next year.

Campbell's 'disappearing bodies' talks of the removal of figures from bodies from images, leaving a mark only symbolizing the horrific events that have happened, but in few cases the violent images showing the true events do surface- but as an act as to what should not be happening as opposed to the pro-event. - The Byrd case. In such cases, it seems horrific events are only to be portrayed in light of good. Instead of images we are given words, describing the situation in gruel detail rather than an off-putting image whilst we eat our breakfast. Words can become more hurtful by association than pictures can- and by extension, mind over pictures.

Sitting, circling, the world is within my own
I sit here thinking of you, grueling pain as you revolve around my head
The more I think of you, a monster you become.

As we can get 'trapped in our own thoughts', it is the idea of the actual event that becomes much more than the event itself. Slavoj Zizek's 'Welcome to the Desert of the Real' the examples 9/11 attacks on the world trade centre, the event is in imaginable, something of such grand scale in filled with terror to a scale incomprehensible to the brain itself- seeing the events on screen becomes much more than the event itself. The repetition and circling thoughts


David Campbell, "Horrific Blindness: Images of Death in Contemporary Media", Journal for Cultural Research, Vol.8, No.1, Routledge, 2004.

Zizek, Slavoj. "Welcome to the Desert of the Real". Re:constructions. 2001. MIT Comparative Media Studies. 9 September 2009

Critical Studies 7 - Neighbourhod over Nationhood

NEIGHBOURHOOD OVER NATIONHOOD

As a change in social history over time has only come to prove that "a new order and intensity" has come to order, openly embracing the new media as the world becomes it's own suburbia. Arjun Appadurai disjuncture and difference in the global cultural economy follows this change in world ethics and cultural transitions of the system we live in.

In an account of the "Philippines affinity for American popular music is rich testimony to the global culture of the hyper real", where in a world of print and internet media culture is able to travel from one country to another easily regardless of who the media is centered around. He describes as the Filipino people 'look back to a world they never lost'- media portraying a life of the 'perfect' American yet this life, so contextualized and rich of fantasy is far from real, it is the hyper real that is being fed to foreign countries. A life of a dreamland that is far from existence.

Baudrillard quotes in 'Astral America'

"Sex, beach and mountains. Sex and beach, beach and mountains. Mountains and sex. A few concepts. Sex and concepts. 'Just a life'.
Everything is destined to reappear as a simulation. Landscapes as photography, women as the sexual scenario, thoughts as writing, terrorism as fashion and the media, events as television. Things seem only to exist by virtue of this strange destiny. You wonder whether the world itself isn't just here to serve as advertising copy in some other world.
When the only physical beauty is created by plastic surgery, the only urban beauty by landscape surgery, the only opinion by opinion poll surgery...and now, with genetic engineering, along comes plastic surgery for the whole human species." (Baudrillard 32)

A world of hyper real, where all is 'perfected' to an image that has become an expectation to the outsider. Suburbia is the perfect example, a neighbourhood perfectly paved, large houses and backyards- foreign to most centered in cities, this suburbia has a level of expectations that is rarely met as living such life is often living next to empty houses, failing economies and bare streets as living in once a dream area fades as children leave to work in cities and commuting between suburbia and work is often a long drive.



Arun Appadurai, "Disjuncture and Difference in the Global Cultural Economy", Modernity at Large: Cultural Dimensions of Globalisation, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1996, pp.27-47

Baudrillard, Jean. America. New York: Verso, 1988.

Sunday, July 19, 2009

Critical Studies 6 - Elizabeth Currid

Where's my mark?
Gatekeepers, Hobbyists, Intermediaries and so forth define the success of Art/Culture as described by Elizabeth Currid. A reading I enjoyed, which as of late- is becoming a regular thing with my attachment to Tze Ming Mok's 'Race You There'. If Mok was my past, Currid is my present. Although not a present I am particularly settled with. These Gatekeepers, Hobbyists, etc. all go through a number of systems Currid mentions- but yet never actually defines the system itself. To form my own opinion of these systems, they are purely based on (like I just said) opinion. If it is a curator, a dealer and so fourths opinion of me that will lay down my future- I am worried to wonder what my future is exactly within the art world.

Death to the extrovert, I am not one of them, and we have all seen how far extroverts can go. If the events, openings etc. are the ground in which Gatekeepers feed from the Hobbyists, and the Intermediaries, this scene is where you need to be in order to survive. At some point in our lives, we have all seen the scene. In fact, most have probably been apart of it for a brief period- it's out fifteen minutes of fame. We are all slaves to the scene; if we defy it then we are the minority that the scene will eventually become. We know this is true from all the fan boys who have now lost their status and hierarchy because of Hollywood’s comic book-movie adaptations, much to the respect of Michael Jackson’s enormous overnight sales topping records since his passing.

I for one, am not particularly interested in gallery openings- for a social factor it isn't exactly my fortay, and your chances of actually taking in the works are slim with the mass crowds of extroverts all trying to dry hump the next curator. If this scene is where the cross fertilization, weak ties of the century happen- where would an introvert make his or her mark? Incapable of sparking a conversation to a stranger, incapable of the approach, there is nothing left for you (..And me) here. Outside of the event, outside of the scene, is there any other way in to the art world? I don't know anyone who's made it. If it's meant to be, if we're destined to make our mark somewhere down the line, how do I make mine?



Elizabeth Currid, "the Economics of a Good Party: Social Mechanisms and the Legitimization of Art/Culture", Journal of Economics and Finance, vol. 31, no. 2, Fall 2007, pp.386-394

Critical Studies 5 - Mok

Race You There

I feel like there is some underlying tie with Tze Ming Mok, in the fact that we're both Asian. Politically and Ethnically. Some tie that to you, obviously a reader from Elam- a school where the majority is white, does not connect with. In a half truth, we have started in the same position, to grow up in Auckland in a central primary school but somewhere along the line I stopped politically calling myself Asian, even though Ethnically I am.

I distinctly recall a conversation reminiscing about primary school, that "Back then being friends with an Asian kid was cool" - that being said looking back at old class photos we only made up 1/10th of the class compared to my high school photos that there was almost 1/2 of us. Following the trend, "Being apart of something is cool", we, Asians, WE were the something cool- the minority that soon became an equal (in numbers), and now that we're no longer the minority it seems we have become less cool. And at the same time, less associated with the heritage. ..some of us anyway.

In some part, I think with the overflow of New Zealand art within schools and within galleries- this has defined art in this corner of the world. This new lavish growing of postmodern..Or almost post-postmodern art from the states is the new thing. "International Look" as Tracey Moffat describes it, is the new eye candy for me and I’m sure others alike.. But at some point someone is going to have to get over the giant oversized pictures on the wall from the latest and greatest Gregory Crewdson/Jeff Wall, and maybe make way for the later up comers, Stephen Shore and his latest (Uncommon Places) of 'mini' prints (Interview: http://www.theartnewspaper.tv/content.php?vid=544) or Lachapelle's cardboard cutouts- as what's in, will no longer be in for much longer. We must make way for the new us. The us that has yet to be defined, and I’m sure by time it is we'll only be looking back on it.


Dir. Unknown. Stephen Shore - Uncommon Places. Stephen Shore, Jean Wainwright. The Art Newspaper, 2009.

Tze Ming Mok, "Race You There", Landfall 208, Dunedin: Otago University Press, 2004, pp. 18-26.

Sunday, May 24, 2009

Critical Studies 4 - Where's my original

"Wherever I go people say to me that they must take me to see New Zealand's last bit of original bush. I have been driven through miles and miles of it since I have been here, and each bit seems to be just as much as the last and just as original as the one before." (Park 2)

It seems to me that the original can never be constant, always formulating and changing with time. From this reading, I take my own relationship with the original- or rather the familiar, as I would like to rename it. It seems with each photograph I create, I look for something new and original to me because it is far more compelling than what I live around each day. The only time I have used an area around where I live was when it was suggested, or rather forced upon me- up until that point I would have never of considered it.

If my surroundings influences the location in which I create my work, is it okay to assume that someone’s experience of my work is in which the same? In a stretch, we are constantly looking for something new. New to the artist, and in consideration, new to the viewer. This role in change is inevitable.

What has come around lately with the rise of the 'art school' genre is the emphasis on the statement. Simply, what photography once was now deals with all matters of concern. The concept renewed into what I believe is the postmodern. What Lyotard stated, the aesthetic properties of the medium are second to the concept and ideas of desire. If it is the failure of a statement, the work itself suffers. The failure to provoke beauty in an object through a simple text could possibly describe the either or two things:
1. The inability of the past to look upon the present. Or
2. The end of post modern.
Jeorg colberg's essay of 'what is a statement' (Colberg) describes the first in the split view of the statement. But it seems with the statement it becomes a split between the past and present or possibly a split between the art school and the outside world. The treatment of work currently resides in those two places, rarely in both.


Geoff Park " Theatre Country", in 'Theatre Country : Essays on Landscape and whenua', Wellington : Victoria University Press,2006, pp.113-127

Colberg, Jeorg. "Defining One's Work." Conscientious. 18 May 2009. Jeorg Colberg. 20 May 2009

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

Critical Studies Three - Post Modernism

French philosopher, Jean-Francois Lyotard's 1984 work 'What is Postmodernism' undoubtedly takes us through the history of demand. If we need the past to define the present, and it is the present that we have currently defined- what's after Postmodernism?

Just as Postmodernism did to Modernism, Modernism undertakes the rules of Realism- redefines in order to fulfill the 'demand' Lyotard speaks of with the end of to experimentation and united front of philosophy. As he quotes Habermas: "Changing the status of aesthetic experience when it is no longer primarily expressed in judgments of taste" (Lyotard 72) Easily could taste and beauty be overlooked, I believe he means taste to be more than first hand judgment that beauty is considered. Background information and concept must be taken into account.

The work of modern artists leaves concept to fulfill beauty as opposed to Avant Garde work which uses the medium- painting, the material to present the un-presented, that being beauty. Through way of brush strokes it is history that is painted not concept. In a forever attempt to achieve art in its purist sense, it seems that the un-presentable is in fact un-presentable. If true, then Postmodernism and by extension Modernism (in its latter) went the opposite way, by doing the negative - the 'missing pieces', looking at concept as a connection point to the viewer to relate to an experience where the un-presentable exists. What Zizek describes as the un-presentable only being real when one experiences either beauty or terror (Zizek 8).

What we take from this is the impossible. At what I consider the defining point of Lyotard essays: "Finally, it must be clear that it is our business not to supply reality but to invent allusions to the conceivable which cannot be presented" (Lyotard 81). In a belief that the un-presentable is impossible, and that creating an allusion can trigger that within the mind is where Postmodernism sits. Sartre's work of 'real and reality', describes each a reality of our own taken from the real. It is that little doorway from real to reality that could represent Beauty and complete the circle. Although to what would be considered a success may need to have the social popularity of Avant Garde painters, or that could possibly only be a status achieved through history.



Jean-Francois Lyotard, "Answering The Queston: What Is Postmodernism?", trans. Regis Durand, in The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge, Minneapolis: University of Minnesorta Press, 1984m pp.71-82.

Zizek, Slavoj. "Welcome to the Desert of the Real". Re:constructions. 2001. MIT Comparative Media Studies. 9 September 2009

Flynn, Thomas. "Jean-Paul Sartre." Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 22 Apr 2004. Stanford University. 6 May 2009.

Friday, April 17, 2009

Critical Studies Two - The Expanded Field

Infinitely malleable, Sculpture is one of those terms that manipulates and forms to the current social context. Rosalind Krauss explores this in her 1979, outdated piece 'Sculpture in the Expanded Field'. It is history that is documented by Sculpture she states. To be created in a single time and place. Rodin's "Gates Of Hell" as described in 'Sculpture in the Expanded Field' uses 'Gates of Hell' as an example for Sculpture to be recreated in a site but non existent in it's original, therefore eliminating it's association with time and place. Which is the beginning for sculpture to become something much more.

It is the Vanguard aesthetics, the ideology of the new, that sculpture reinvests itself with. A slow process, but yet something that does happens effectively. "The new is made comfortable by being made familiar" krauss states in 'Sculpture in the Expanded Field'. Without significant leaps being recorded as a new significant leap, it is the history of sculpture that takes the blow, lessening the gap between old and new. An effect that has allowed sculpture to have such a manipulative term.

Everything may be considered new but it is all translated differently between people. Therefore it is reduced to time and space. The allowance of indexes, indices and signs are used to familiarize ourselves with the unfamiliar. More than art, we've taken sides with the unfamiliar- embraced it or treated it as hostile. For example Lakshmi, the eight limbed baby born with isciopagus. (Surgery on eight-limbed baby Lakshmi 'a success' 2) Warmed and worshipped by some, or rejected by others. It is the distance between science and faith. If we have been taught anything from children books and Hollywood cinema it is that we throw sides between the unfamiliar. We take example in Trousdale and Wises' Beauty and the Beast, Spielberg's E.T, with the understanding of a free willing mind against an older inhospitable mind.

Is it with time we become more hostile within ourselves? Critical of the new, less opening to the new experience, I personally find myself pondering what critical parts of my life do I take for granted. Pushed to stand my ground with what I know and what I don’t, or am unwilling to change. Is it a natural reaction to redefine the unfamiliar with what we know already in order to understand it? And if this is the case, restriction of the process can only create a future that falls short.


Roaslind Krauss, "Sculpture in the Expanded Field", October, Vol.8 (Spring, 1979), pp.30-44

O'Connor, Ashling. "Surgery on eight-limbed baby Lakshmi 'a success'". Times Online. 7 Nov. 2007. The Times 29 April 2009.

Dir. Gary Trousdale, Kirk Wise. "Beauty and the Beast". Paige O'Hare, Robby Benson. Walt Disney Feature Animation, 1991.

Dir. Steven Spielberg. "E.T: The Extra-Terrestrial". Henry Thomas, Dee Wallace, Robert MacNaughton, Drew Barrymore. Universal Pictures, 1982.

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

Critical Studies One - What is an Image?

WJT Mitchell, in 1986, he comments on the work of Mark Twain’s and Doris Lessing’s theory of ‘what is an image?’ is the exploration of limits in pictorial expression and language. The idea of simplification of pictorial works through language- specifically through painting (but what I familiarize myself with in this essay is photography, which I believe the theory still applies.) Taking an experience from viewing an image and explaining it with language is what Lessing argues as incapable. Taking the notion of story telling and trying to convey it through a static image is what Lessing notes as ‘grotesque forms of allegory’ (Mitchell 41) as explaining progressive forms to static forms does not translate. Twain also forward for the theory rather than criticizing the idea explains the limits. Which we know as the failed translation. From which we further take language and break it down into Henri Van Liers work of ‘signs, indexes and indices’ (17-20).

In Agreement with Twain and Lessing that a full experience, but not an experience at all, is lost through the translation into language, the work of Henri Van Lier’s ‘Real vs. Reality’ (36-38) can help elaborate. From the present time, what we currently experience should be noted as real, it couldn’t be explained in any shape or form created by humanity. That is to say the quasi-relations of the in-itself by Sartre or rather it “is not yet domesticated by our technical, scientific and social relations” (Van Lier 36). Contrast to real, is what we have domesticated from it- in any form, language or pictorial expression we take of the real, becomes reality. A system needed to function within humans for able-bodied communication- breaking down real into reality through signs, indexes and indices. A variety of international intentional and non-intentional signs and symbols that indicate to our brain. The notion that a red car is the colour red.


Van Lier, Henri. Philosophy of Photography. Belgium: Leuven University Press, 2007.

W.J.T Mitchell, "what Is An Image?, Iconology: Image, Text, Ideology. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1986, pp.40-46.